Best Lube for Butt Plugs: What to Use for Silicone, Metal & Glass

Written by: Camilla Jakobsson

|

|

Time to read: 6 min


The best lube for a butt plug depends on what the plug is made from and how long you plan to use it.


For most toys, a thick water-based lube is a practical place to start. It is easy to clean up and works with a wide range of toy materials. If you use a metal or glass butt plug and want a longer-lasting glide, a silicone-based lube may also be an option.

If you are still choosing the toy itself, browse our anal plug collection to compare different sizes, shapes, and materials.


Below, we’ll compare the best lube choices for silicone, metal, and glass butt plugs, plus a few current ThatMood picks worth considering.


How We Chose the Best Lubes for Butt Plugs


We focused on current ThatMood lubricants that make sense for anal play and butt plug use.


We looked at the lube base, thickness, how long it lasts, cleanup, and whether it is suitable for common butt plug materials like silicone, metal, and glass.

We also gave extra weight to formulas made for anal use and avoided making numbing or desensitizing lubes a main recommendation, since being able to feel discomfort is important during anal play.


Each product also needed a current ThatMood product page before making the final list.


Best Lubes for Butt Plugs


The right lube depends on your butt plug material and how long you want it to last.


For most silicone plugs, a thick water-based lube is the safest place to start. For metal or glass plugs, you may also have the option of a longer-lasting silicone-based lube.


Here are four current ThatMood picks that cover the most useful situations.


1. Naturals Sassy


Best overall for butt plugs

Naturals Sassy is a thick water-based anal gel made for extra glide and cushioning during anal play. The thicker texture helps it stay where you put it, which can be useful when inserting or wearing a butt plug.


Because it is water-based, it is also a practical choice when you want something easy to clean up. The formula does not use desensitizing ingredients, so you can still pay attention to how your body feels during play.


Bottle of Naturals Sassy water-based anal lubricant

2. Aneros Sessions 4.2 Oz Water Based Lubricant


Best for silicone butt plugs


Aneros Sessions is a water-based lubricant that works well when you are using a silicone butt plug and want to avoid compatibility concerns with silicone-based lube.


The formula is made for toy use and gives you a smooth glide without feeling overly heavy. It is also glycerin-free and paraben-free, which may appeal if you prefer a simpler water-based formula.


Bottle of Aneros Sessions water-based lubricant

3. Ride Bodyworkx Water 2 Oz


Best thick water-based option


Ride Bodyworkx Water has a thicker gel texture that helps it stay in place instead of running off quickly. That can make it a practical option for butt plug use, especially if you want the compatibility of a water-based lube with a little more cushioning.


It is also easy to clean up and works well for people who prefer a thicker feel without switching to a silicone-based formula.


Bottle of Aneros Sessions water-based lubricant

4. Spunk Lube Pure Silicone


Best for metal or glass butt plugs


If you use a metal or glass butt plug and want a longer-lasting glide, Spunk Lube Pure Silicone is the pick to consider. Silicone-based lube tends to stay slippery longer than water-based formulas, which can be helpful during longer sessions.


Because this is a silicone-based lubricant, I would keep the recommendation specific to compatible non-silicone plugs. If your butt plug is made from silicone, check the manufacturer’s guidance and use a compatible water-based lube instead.


Bottle of Spunk Lube Pure Silicone lubricant

Which Lube Works With Your Butt Plug Material?


Your butt plug material can help determine which type of lube makes the most sense.


Silicone Butt Plugs


A water-based lube is the simplest choice for most silicone butt plugs. It gives you plenty of slip without the compatibility questions that can come with silicone-based formulas.

If you want to use another type of lube, check the toy manufacturer’s instructions first.


Metal Butt Plugs


Metal plugs give you more flexibility with lube. You can use a water-based formula, or choose a silicone-based lube when you want something that stays slippery longer.


Glass Butt Plugs


Glass plugs also work with a wider range of lubricants. Water-based lube is easy to clean up, while silicone-based lube can be useful when you want longer-lasting glide.


Still deciding which material suits you? Our guide to the differences between silicone and glass butt plugs can help you compare how each one feels and what it is like to use.


Whatever material you use, start with enough lube to make insertion comfortable and add more whenever you need it.



How to Use Lube With a Butt Plug


Use enough lube to coat both the butt plug and the area around the anus before insertion. Anal tissue does not produce its own lubrication, so adding enough slip matters for comfort.


Start slowly and add more lube if you feel extra friction or dryness. If anything feels sharp, painful, or unusually uncomfortable, stop rather than trying to push through it.

For longer wear, check in with how your body feels and reapply lube when needed. Water-based formulas may need to be refreshed more often than silicone-based ones.


When you are finished, clean the butt plug according to its material and the manufacturer’s care instructions.

For more care tips, see our guide on how to clean butt plugs after use.


A mini-cart with two bottles of lube in

Which Lube Is Best for Your Butt Plug?


For most butt plugs, a thick water-based lube is the easiest place to start.


If your plug is made from silicone, water-based lube is the simplest compatibility choice. If you use a metal or glass plug and want a longer-lasting glide, a silicone-based lube may also work well.

The best option is the one that matches your toy material, feels comfortable, and gives you enough slip without making the experience harder to control.


If you are still choosing the toy itself, our guide to top-rated booty plugs can help you compare different styles and options.


When in doubt, check the toy manufacturer’s care and compatibility guidance before trying a new lubricant.


Related Blog Posts

Frequently Asked Questions About Lube for Butt Plugs

What is the best lube for a butt plug?

A thick water-based lube is a good starting point for most butt plugs because it works with a wide range of toy materials and is easy to clean up.

For metal or glass plugs, a silicone-based lube may also be useful if you want a longer-lasting glide.

What is the best lube for a silicone butt plug?

Water-based lube is the simplest choice for most silicone butt plugs.

If you want to use a silicone-based or hybrid formula, check the toy manufacturer’s compatibility guidance first.

What is the best lube for a metal butt plug?

Both water-based and silicone-based lubes can work with metal butt plugs.

Choose water-based if you want easier cleanup, or consider silicone-based lube when you want the glide to last longer.

Can I use silicone lube with a butt plug?

It depends on the material of the plug.

Silicone lube can be a useful option with compatible materials such as metal or glass. For silicone toys, check the manufacturer’s instructions before using a silicone-based lubricant.

How much lube should I use with a butt plug?

Use enough to coat the plug and the area around the anus before insertion.

If you notice extra friction or dryness, stop and add more. There is no advantage to trying to use as little as possible.

Do I need to reapply lube while wearing a butt plug?

You may need to, especially with water-based formulas during longer sessions.

Pay attention to how your body feels and add more lube if the area starts to feel dry or less comfortable.

Portrait image of Camilla Jakobsson .

Camilla Jakobsson

With 30 years of writing experience spanning across multiple niches, my thirst for knowledge knows no bounds. Writing has always been a passion of mine, and I hope one day to become a best-selling author, but for now, my sights are set on the sex industry. I'm grateful to be part of the revolution- to empower women and to free us all from outdated stigmas surrounding female sexual health and desires.

Sources

Leave a comment